Internet Community Service

I was just reading an article about how the Canadians are wanting to ban child pornogrpahy, racial hatred and promotion of violence against women, which left me wondering… Is banning someone from Internet access for 7-years that much of a fitting punishment? I mean, sheesh! You couldn’t get a job for 7 years - even BestBuy store clerks need to use the Internet for company e-mail, price checks, etc.

Racial hatred strikes me as a rather difficult thing to police, as it is… Where should the line be drawn between humour and hurt? What if it’s just an accidental slip of the tongue? Things happen, and I know in the past that I’ve said something which someone has found racist unintenitonally. Sometimes I think it’s a bit silly how the person interpereted (as it was not intended to be insulting in the slightest) but people view things in different ways. As ‘Baa Baa Black Sheep’ can now be classed as racism here in the UK as it is, what happens if we’re racist wihtout realising it?

So how’s Internet Community Service sounding? We make the poor sods who find insulting people based on their colour amusing, clean up comment spam on our blogs, edit Wikipedia articles, etc… To me, it seems like a win-win situation. Enforcing it may be slightly harder, but heck. That comes later. ;)

How should we police the net? Should we even police the net? I’m against general censorship (like in China), but I agree that porn, etc should be dealt with or at least made sure that people know what they’re viewing before doing so.

del.icio.us Digg Technorati

Related Products



Related Posts

Easiest. Money. Ever. Text Link Ads - Join now!

RSS feed | Trackback URI

6 Comments »

Comment by Sumesh
MyAvatars 0.2

April 22nd, 2007 at 5:01 am

Yes, adult stuff and racism are two big problems…..

But then again, censorship is not the answer. That will only make people find alternate methods…..like proxies.

As for kids, there are two ways to protect them from porn:

1) strict filters(local apps)
2) pray well :P

Comment by David Wilkinson
MyAvatars 0.2

April 22nd, 2007 at 6:50 am

Isn’t a filter basically just censoring the information that you can view? Censorship probably isn’t the best way to go about it, I agree. Instead, content should be stripped from the net and the persons behind it punished.

Enter! Internet Community Service! ;)

 
 
MyAvatars 0.2

April 22nd, 2007 at 7:45 am

[…] Hate mail sucks at the best of times - we’ve probably all received some from an anonymous looney at some point and we know how much it gets to you. You’ll go off and think about it for hours-on-end wondering about what the person says, and coming up with counter-arguments against every scrap of detail they put into the message (even though they probably only spent two or three minutes firing off the piece of junk). I think that hate-mail is just as big a crime as any other thing and we need to start punishing those who commit the more serious offences. Of course again, we have to draw a line between playground arguments and full-blown organized attacks on people, but something has to be done. Something has to change… Internet Community Service? […]

 
Comment by Joel Stephano
MyAvatars 0.2

April 22nd, 2007 at 6:19 pm

I remember looking at a few ‘net police’ sites set up a couple of years ago. It’s quite interesting to see how the system worked. Unfortunately, I’ve forgotten the name of it. Google doesn’t enlighten me…

Comment by David Wilkinson
MyAvatars 0.2

April 22nd, 2007 at 7:20 pm

I saw a few a couple of years back, but truth be told, they really sucked. All the blackhat marketers get whimpy (thinking that these guys will move onto ‘em next) and start ranting against the methods used…

In turn, the ‘police’ get seen as criminals. ;)

Comment by Joel Stephano
MyAvatars 0.2

April 23rd, 2007 at 3:48 pm

Yeah, because people worry about how hackers could be trained to hack and bring down sites. Some say that this is illegal, but I’d call doing that a citizens arrest!

 
 
 

Name (required)

E-mail (required - never shown publicly)

Website
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)